The 2026 State of
MCP Server Security
Empirical evaluation of 47 canonical Model Context Protocol servers across 254,747 GitHub stars. Tested against 6 deterministic execution sink vectors.
The 6 Evaluation Vectors (MSHB-2026 Methodology)
Every repository is audited without external dependencies via deterministic static AST analysis:
Detects unvalidated subprocess.Popen, execSync, spawn calls that allow arbitrary tool escape.
Flags dangerous eval(), new Function(), or in-memory script generation sinks.
Scans for unbounded file writes, directory traversal, and unauthenticated deletion endpoints.
Audits process.env / os.environ dumping, reflection, and JSON serialization risks.
Maps outbound socket and HTTP connections to ensure tools cannot exfiltrate context to unverified hosts.
Verifies presence of SECURITY.md, deterministic package lockfiles, and OSI-compliant licensing.
Benchmark Leaderboard (Ranked by Security Score)
Click any repository to inspect its line-cited findings and cryptographic commit tree SHA.
| Rank | Repository | GitHub Stars | Score / 100 | Grade | Governance & Findings | Verification |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ๐ฅ | koala73/worldmonitorSHA: 98f471f8 ยท AGPL-3.0 | โ 90,875 | 98 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| ๐ฅ | apify/apify-mcp-serverSHA: 017b00bd ยท MIT | โ 15,704 | 98 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| ๐ฅ | modelcontextprotocol/inspectorSHA: e3217388 ยท NOASSERTION | โ 11,220 | 98 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #4 | pipeshub-ai/pipeshub-aiSHA: 52f1c8e9 ยท Apache-2.0 | โ 3,901 | 98 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #5 | stripe/agent-toolkitSHA: 5091f729 ยท MIT | โ 2,033 | 98 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #6 | coinbase/agentkitSHA: f2f3e8c1 ยท NOASSERTION | โ 1,353 | 98 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #7 | codepawl/crucibleSHA: dd51b3c7 ยท MIT | โ 657 | 98 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #8 | AmrDab/clawdcursorSHA: 92f5f248 ยท MIT | โ 406 | 98 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #9 | labsai/EDDISHA: 3c32fb84 ยท Apache-2.0 | โ 389 | 98 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #10 | jdubois/boot-uiSHA: 0f19526f ยท Apache-2.0 | โ 329 | 98 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #11 | bardesss/arr-mcpSHA: 57a8feb9 ยท MIT | โ 100 | 98 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #12 | fathomise/MailFathomSHA: 4b5032d9 ยท AGPL-3.0 | โ 21 | 98 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #13 | assafelovic/gpt-researcherSHA: ddd4db36 ยท Apache-2.0 | โ 30,644 | 96 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #14 | lastmile-ai/mcp-agentSHA: f62d8493 ยท Apache-2.0 | โ 8,575 | 96 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #15 | lemma-work/lemma-platformSHA: a6fb17ab ยท AGPL-3.0 | โ 640 | 96 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #16 | openaccountants/openaccountantsSHA: 1fb7c019 ยท AGPL-3.0 | โ 478 | 96 | A+ | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #17 | ridafkih/keeper.shSHA: 7eadbfb4 ยท AGPL-3.0 | โ 1,443 | 93 | A | No deterministic dependency lockfile (`uv.lock` / `package-lock.json`) | Inspect Audit โ |
| #18 | archestra-ai/archestraSHA: c762c76e ยท NOASSERTION | โ 4,445 | 92 | A | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #19 | browserbase/mcp-server-browserbaseSHA: 3e6f5346 ยท Apache-2.0 | โ 3,398 | 92 | A | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #20 | TencentCloudBase/CloudBase-AI-ToolkitSHA: 800823b6 ยท MIT | โ 1,163 | 92 | A | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #21 | vostride/agent-qaSHA: d443e720 ยท NOASSERTION | โ 856 | 92 | A | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #22 | redis/mcp-redisSHA: 3ffd548f ยท MIT | โ 641 | 92 | A | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #23 | andrea-magni/MARSSHA: 0627a951 ยท MPL-2.0 | โ 400 | 92 | A | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #24 | vstorm-co/agenticosSHA: 00d65faf ยท Apache-2.0 | โ 342 | 92 | A | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #25 | oktopeak/clio-mcpSHA: 753da456 ยท MIT | โ 27 | 92 | A | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #26 | blackwell-systems/mcp-assertSHA: 6a11e4f2 ยท MIT | โ 26 | 92 | A | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #27 | Marker-Inc-Korea/AutoRAGSHA: 37b2d5af ยท Apache-2.0 | โ 5,736 | 90 | A | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #28 | jackulau/coding.shSHA: 3fb42b35 ยท MIT | โ 112 | 90 | A | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #29 | LING71671/open-reverselabSHA: 64112646 ยท Apache-2.0 | โ 1,371 | 88 | A | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #30 | pydantic/pydantic-aiSHA: 5616c219 ยท MIT | โ 21,014 | 86 | A | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #31 | keboola/mcp-serverSHA: 0b6ce83c ยท MIT | โ 85 | 86 | A | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #32 | Nano-Empire-Ai/nanoempire-webSHA: 84936f02 ยท MIT | โ 1 | 86 | A | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #33 | mendableai/firecrawl-mcp-serverSHA: 6bd077c6 ยท MIT | โ 7,758 | 84 | B | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #34 | jgravelle/jcodemunch-mcpSHA: 937a2f10 ยท NOASSERTION | โ 2,840 | 84 | B | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #35 | Filippo-Venturini/ctxvaultSHA: e0cceada ยท MIT | โ 69 | 84 | B | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #36 | CorpusIQ/corpusiq-docsSHA: bda1c767 ยท NOASSERTION | โ 29 | 84 | B | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #37 | alpacahq/alpaca-mcp-serverSHA: 72b2493c ยท MIT | โ 1,057 | 82 | B | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #38 | SamurAIGPT/Seedance-2.5-APISHA: 8738e4f4 ยท MIT | โ 510 | 81 | B | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #39 | duhu2000/dsh-mcp-connectorSHA: 66f6747c ยท MIT | โ 126 | 81 | B | No deterministic dependency lockfile (`uv.lock` / `package-lock.json`) | Inspect Audit โ |
| #40 | ZeroDayEvil/ai-security-toolSHA: 8a918419 ยท MIT | โ 1,301 | 79 | B | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #41 | DitriXNew/EDT-MCPSHA: d2cf6c8b ยท AGPL-3.0 | โ 326 | 79 | B | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #42 | makenotion/notion-mcp-serverSHA: cf16e5c2 ยท MIT | โ 4,693 | 78 | B | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #43 | skulitom/PixelboltSHA: ab62ddda ยท MIT | โ 114 | 77 | B | No deterministic dependency lockfile (`uv.lock` / `package-lock.json`) | Inspect Audit โ |
| #44 | punkpeye/fastmcpSHA: 60ba7fd8 ยท MIT | โ 3,283 | 76 | B | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #45 | vitali87/code-graph-ragSHA: 24b29d79 ยท MIT | โ 5,348 | 73 | C | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
| #46 | syiibfs-hash/cc-agent-brainSHA: 16328a03 ยท MIT | โ 83 | 69 | C | Missing `SECURITY.md` vulnerability disclosure policy | Inspect Audit โ |
| #47 | xerj-org/xerjSHA: 50e4ffde ยท Apache-2.0 | โ 18,825 | 60 | C | Zero critical execution sinks detected | Inspect Audit โ |
Head-to-Head MCP Security Showdowns
Side-by-side 6-vector security and governance comparisons across leading MCP categories:
Firecrawl MCP vs Browserbase MCP
Stripe Toolkit vs Coinbase AgentKit
Pydantic-AI vs LastMile mcp-agent
MCP Inspector vs FastMCP
Notion MCP vs PipesHub AI
Redis MCP vs Keboola MCP
Is Your MCP Server Verified for Enterprise Deployment?
Add the SkillProof CI/CD security gate to your repo. Servers scoring โฅ85 receive verified status, dynamic Shields.io badges, and inclusion in the official quarterly State of MCP Security Report.